Please email submissions to submissions@monadjournal.com
We accept: audio; visual; typed and imagistic submissions with, where necessary, an associated exegesis.
Monad journal is currently accepting submissions that examine, critically evaluate or reflexively critique contemporary occulture and occultural practices (and practitioners) that engage in progressive personal and (oc)cultural transformation.
We are particularly interested in the various intersections between the esoteric/occultural, artistic, political, technological, scientific, educational, therapeutic and the other-than-human. For further information on our mission and ethos, visit our homepage.
We will consider submissions that focus on methods, modes and makers of occulture.
All submitted items must be scholastic in nature and can be presented in a number of ways. We will accept: audio; visual; word-based and imagistic submissions with, where necessary, an associated exegesis. We take the clear position that an exegesis, though perhaps necessary for proper contextualisation, is not a ‘legitimising component’. (Arnold, 2005, p.38) We recognise ‘theory and practice [as] inextricably linked and mutually dependent.’ (Scrivener, 2000, p.1) Exegesis is only required when the scholastic assertions of the work are not inherent within the artefact. This journal has been founded recognising that the focus on exegeses as ‘legitimising’ practice, or, indeed, asserting a primacy to typed articles more generally, is a disservice to the inherently rich and high-resolution textual qualities of artefacts borne of practice-based and practice-led research. More traditional, type-based textual submissions (articles) are equally acceptable.
All submissions will undergo a rigorous peer-review process.
Significantly re-visioned and adapted from adapted from Scrivener’s (2000) work on benchmarks for research projects within art and design, we present the following criteria against which Monad Journal assesses all contributions but are particularly helpful with respect to evaluating nontextual, practice-based and practitioner-derived contributions.
Is it an original, high-quality, and engaging artefact/contribution that:
- displays (oc)cultural preoccupations and enables (oc)cultural transformation
- contributes to and/or critically reflects on personal experience and personal transformation
- explores the relationship between the artefact(s)/contribution and broader (oc)cultural issues
- communicates knowledge, learning and insight
- relates to larger networks and projects of (oc)cultural significance
- reveals (oc)cultural creativity’s critical, transformative, methodical, and/or reflexive capacities
AUDIO/VISUAL: Min 30 secs – Maximum circa 20 min (with supporting exegesis if appropriate)
TYPED ARTICLE: Min 4,000 – Max 8,000 words
IMAGISTIC: Min 1 – Max 10 (with supporting exegesis if appropriate) Note: More than 10 full size images would need to be submitted as a video submission: for example, slideshow, video essay etc.
MULTIMEDIA: One can blend these forms of writing, please use the above guidelines to infer accumulative min and max values for content.
What to include…
Contributors details
All authors attached to a given submission should include their:
- full name,
- email address,
- any affiliation,
- a brief biography (keep as brief as possible, maximum of 100 words/author).
- If available, an ORCID ID and/or any social media network links and website/blog info.
Keywords
Provide between 3–8 keywords.
An abstract
- Abstracts may be typed, audio or video.
- For a typed abstract, provide a maximum of 300 words.
- For video and audio, please provide a maximum of 3 minutes (with a separate transcript of any wording included).
Abstracts may also be typed, audio or video.
Your submission
- All submissions should be in English. British English or American English is acceptable, but submissions should maintain internal consistency throughout. If textual elements are submitted in other languages, please provide an English translation.
- Please ensure that typed submissions (articles or exegeses of submitted artefacts) are sent as a MS Word document. No other formats please: .doc/.docx only!
- Quoted/cited sources and any footnotes should be formatted in accordance with the Chicago Referencing Style Notes and Bibliography system (sometimes referred to as Chicago Footnote).
- With respect to artefacts, please provide us with the highest-quality version you have. For images, 300+ dpi is preferred. For video and audio, as lossless and high-quality as you have available. Send us download links or use a transfer provider (such as WeTransfer, MediaFire, etc.)
We support open access research, open collaboration and the Creative Commons initiative.
A word on copyright
Monad is a open source journal and all content on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0). You are responsible for ensuring that any third-party materials included in your submissions may also be shared under Creative Commons license and that you can evidence all necessary permissions where required.
Make sure all third-party content, even content in the public domain, is fully and accurately attributed.
Peer Review Process
Monad Journal advocates open, collaborative and supportive research. The nature of contributions to this journal means that although all reasonable measures are taken to retain the anonymity of contributors for review purposes, we recognise that, practically speaking, their identities may remain discernible. We initially implemented an open and transparent peer review process. Our reasoning was that using a transparent peer review process in a journal offers several benefits, especially when aligned with occultural studies, which is rooted in reflexivity, critical epistemology, and relational ethics. Unfortunately, in practice, we discovered that this process was pragmatically untenable and have reverted to a primarily blind peer review process. This is because of a number of factors. Firstly, there are power dynamics within academia that require those on the lesser end of the power differential to be protected. Secondly, peer reviewers should feel free to express their perspective without fear of any negative repercussions. Thirdly, it was surmised that publishing reviewers’ comments required additional unpaid labour on the part of the reviewers.
Our hypothesis that reviewers’ comments and identities being published along with the relevant contributions would encourage more constructive, fair, and rigorous engagement failed to recognise that this would be counteracted by fear of repercussion due to power dynamics within the academic field. In an open, transparent peer review process, there is no safety net for either peer reviewer or contributor. The need for reviewers to speak their minds is just as important as the structure that would facilitate that. Given the nature of academia, more broadly, we understand that there are power differentials that benefit the hegemony. We found that with the open process, this only supported hegemony and didn’t give the supported space required for early career researchers, independent scholars and practitioners that we had hoped it would. Keeping things anonymous prevents biases from infiltrating contributors’ work and allows the completed contribution to stand on its own merits. Academia is not a level playing field, and those disagreeing with established scholars need to be protected by anonymity.
Although it would be ideal to have the review available as a part of the overall conversation around the work, in practice, this had the potential to undermine the veracity and integrity of the completed contribution. In the unlikely event that any questions should ever be raised regarding the quality and integrity of the peer review process, then biases, potential conflicts of interest, and examples of good practice remain a matter of record.
Work cited
Arnold, Josie, “The PhD in Writing Accompanied By An Exegesis.” Journal of University Teaching & Learning Practice,vol. 2, no. 1., 2005. http://ro.uow.edu.au/jutlp/vol2/iss1/5
McLaughlin, Cavan, “Occultural Production as Re-Vision and Weird Worlding [PhD Thesis], University of Northampton, 2025.
Scrivener, Steven. “Reflection in and on action and practice in creative-production doctoral projects in art and design.” Working Papers in Art and Design vol. 1, no. 1, 2000.